- Government estimate
- $4,000,000
- What the agency expected to pay
- Winning bid
- $3,820,000
- The amount awarded
- Difference from estimate
- $180,000 below
- Bids received
- 8
- Range of bids
- $3,820,000 to $4,395,000
- Lowest to highest price offered
- Awarded to
- Northstar Civil Construction
- Award date
- May 27, 2026
The award came in $180,000 (5%) below the government estimate. The government estimate is what the agency expected the work to cost before it saw any bids.
About This Contract
The City repaired the Market Street bridge deck with a new concrete overlay, joints, and steel repairs.
Rehabilitation of the Market Street bridge deck: hydro-demolition, latex-modified concrete overlay, expansion joint replacement, and structural steel repairs.
Why This Vendor Was Selected
Northstar Civil Construction submitted the lowest responsive, responsible bid, seven percent under the engineer's estimate.
Bid tabulation
All bids as opened and recorded by the Procurement Office. Responsive means the bid met the requirements the solicitation set out.
- Northstar Civil Construction$3,820,000
Westbridge, OH
Awarded - Riverstone Concrete$3,905,000
Canton, OH
Responsive - Cardinal Paving$3,988,400
Massillon, OH
Responsive - Harborview Engineering$4,050,000
Cleveland, OH
Responsive - Ironbridge Electric$4,120,000
Westbridge, OH
Non-Responsive - Summit Building Systems$4,200,000
Cleveland, OH
Responsive - Copperfield Plumbing$4,310,000
Westbridge, OH
Responsive - BlueLine Utilities$4,395,000
Youngstown, OH
Responsive
Protests
Bid protests are part of the procurement record but this agency does not publish them on the portal. You can request them through a public records request.
Solicitation Documents
- PW-26-049-IFB.pdfIFB · Feb 27, 2026
- PW-26-049-Notice-of-Intent-to-Award.pdfAward · May 23, 2026
- PW-26-049-Bid-Tabulation.pdfBid Tabulation · May 28, 2026
Procurement Timeline
Every stage this purchase passed through, from planning to the end of the contract.
Where this stands now: Completion. The contract is still running. It will be marked complete when it ends.
Planning
CompleteThe agency defined the need and prepared the solicitation.
Published
CompleteFeb 27, 2026, 10:49 AM EST
Posted publicly and open to any qualified company.
Questions
CompleteMar 29, 2026, 11:49 AM EDT
The question period closed. Answered questions stay published with the solicitation.
Addenda
CompleteNo addenda were issued. The solicitation was not changed after it was posted.
Bid deadline
CompleteApr 8, 2026, 11:49 AM EDT
Bidding closed at this time. Late submissions cannot be accepted.
Bid opening
CompleteApr 8, 2026, 11:49 AM EDT
8 bids were received and opened electronically by Sarah Chen. Witnessed by Diane Foster, Senior Buyer; Marcus Webb, Facilities Project Manager.
Evaluation
CompleteEvaluation finished and the panel produced a recommendation.
Intent to award
CompleteThe agency published its intended awardee, so other bidders had notice before the contract was final.
Protest period
CompleteBidders had a set window to formally challenge the decision. No protest is published for this solicitation.
Award
CompleteMay 30, 2026, 11:49 AM EDT
The award was published after 8 bids were received and opened.
Contract
CompleteJune 16, 2026
Contract C-26-0041 started at $3,820,000.
Amendments
CompleteAugust 10, 2026
2 executed changes took the contract from $3,820,000 to $3,947,500.
Completion
Happening nowJanuary 22, 2027
The contract is still running. It will be marked complete when it ends.